Every day brings about an argument with my roommates about sports. These days, a visitor would likely hear me quibbling with one of them over the number of Big East teams that deserve to be dancing in March. During the college football season, the arguments predictably led to a debate over the current playoff system.
Which is why my eyes lit up when my roommate suggested what very few, if any, had ever thought of.
“What if college basketball used the BCS system?” he asked.
Hmm…what if?
I should say right now that I love March Madness. The tournament is a lot of fun, and I would never want to see it go away. But before you dismiss the following idea, consider the proposal below.
Let’s say college basketball did use the BCS system. There would be no tournament. The two best teams out of 347 Division 1 teams would play for the national championship. As for the rest? The next 32 could play in the NIT perhaps. Or maybe I develop “bowl” games for the 62 next-best. Either way, it’s not important. What is important is how college basketball would determine its national champion.
My roommate and I agree that if the BCS is used, it would have to triple the field to six eligible teams because there are about three times as many D1 basketball schools (347) as FBS football schools (120). So six teams make the BCS championship, and the champion is determined as follows:
#6 at #3 (winner plays at #2)
#5 at #4 (winner plays at #1)
Winner of 1 vs 4/5 plays winner of 2 vs 3/6 on a neutral court for the title.
Easy enough.
Now on to how to determine the six eligible teams.
The BCS uses the Coaches Poll, Harris Poll and average of six BCS computers to determine the football rankings. In college basketball, there is a Coaches Poll but not a Harris Poll. I suggest replacing Harris with RPI. Though I think the AP Poll is more valid than the Coaches Poll, using both AP and Coaches Polls would not be good because the top six are usually identical.
Four of the six BCS computers also rank college basketball teams (Anderson & Hester and Richard Billingsley do not), so I can use the same computer methods. Ken Pomeroy will be used as a fifth computer. Because there are only five computers, I will throw out only the median ranking, rather than the highest and/or lowest.
So who would be eligible to play for a national championship right now?
The top six in the Coaches Poll are Kansas, Kentucky, Villanova, Purdue, Syracuse and Duke.
The RPI reads Kansas, Duke, Kentucky, Syracuse, West Virginia and Villanova.
All five computers have Kansas ranked #1. Since both the Coaches and RPI also have the Jayhawks #1, it’s easy to give them the #1 seed in the basketball BCS. Their average is 1.
Kentucky does not do too well in the computer rankings. Only the Colley Matrix has the Wildcats #2. The median is 4 and the average is 4.5. Averaging together with the Coaches and RPI gives them a 3.17.
Pomeroy’s computer is going to bring Villanova down. The Wildcats are ranked #15 in that computer, bring the computer average to 5.75 and the overall average to 4.92.
Purdue got a big win over Ohio State Wednesday, but they are still a consistent 6 in all but one computer, giving them a 5.75 computer average. Overall, the Boilermakers are a 6.25 because of their low RPI.
Syracuse has a huge game with Georgetown tonight that could alter the rankings, but for now, the Orange have a computer average of 3.25 and an overall average of 4.08.
Duke is ranked sixth in the Coaches Poll but has the #2 RPI. The Blue Devils have a computer average of 4.5 and an overall average of 4.17.
Outside the top six, West Virginia seems to be the most likely contender. However, the computers spit out an average of 8.67 for the Mountaineers, giving them an overall average of 6.89. Purdue’s 6.25 barely beats West Virginia for the sixth spot.
The only other team in consideration is Kansas State. The Wildcats’ computer average is 9.25, pulling the overall average down to 7.75.
So the six teams in the tournament happen to be the top six in the Coaches Poll. The matchups are as follows:
(6) Purdue at (3) Syracuse
(5) Villanova at (4) Duke
Purdue/Syracuse at (2) Kentucky
Villanova/Duke at (1) Kansas
Championship on neutral court
I know you are lying if you say you would be even the slightest bit intrigued by this. Imagine how West Virginia fans would feel. The Mountaineers are the TCU of college basketball. Then again, West Virginia did lose to Purdue, who has the sixth and final spot.
How fun would it be to watch college basketball every night, knowing that a loss by any of the top six could make way for #7 or #8 to slide up into the field.
Consider reducing the field to four teams. Then Villanova, ranked #3 in the Coaches Poll, would be out.
Again, this is purely just for fun. Everyone imagines what it would be like if college football used college basketball’s system.
Thank you, roomie, for making me imagine the opposite. Even for just one day.